top of page

Perfect Silence | Black Gay & Lonely AF!

  • Writer: J.R. Whittington
    J.R. Whittington
  • Mar 8
  • 5 min read
Kind Eyes
Kind Eyes

This is my Black, queer Sex and the City—Black don't crack, love still dangerous, desire loud, standards high, heart open, and me refusing to shrink for anybody's comfort.

This that old-school diary vibe — scribbles-in-the-margins, headphones blasting, secrets that make me naked between each line.


Missed an essay — these stories flow chronologically, but each one can shine solo. Peep what came before? Just adds a little extra spice.


—kind eyes.


Not the "I'm trying to seem approachable" kind. The real kind. The kind that make you believe he actually means it when he asks how you're doing. The kind that listen before they speak.


He's tall. Biracial—definitely mixed with Asian, and I think Asian men are hot, though I don't ask because that's not the first-date question you lead with. Not when you're trying to be evolved, mature, the kind of person who cares about substance over details.

He sits down and I realize immediately: He's not my type.


Not even close.


Physically, anyway.


My body doesn't react. No flutter in my chest. No heat rising. No magnetic pull that makes you lean in closer without realizing it, that makes your skin wake up and pay attention.

Just... nothing.


Flatline.


My dick sits there like a disappointed theater critic giving one star before the show even starts. Curtain up, house lights down, and the lead actor can't even get an entrance applause.


Mr. Flatline. That's what I'll call him. Not because he's flat—he's wonderful, actually. But because that's what my body did the second he sat down. Flattened. Silent. Refused to show up for the audition.


And I'm sitting there thinking: This is exactly what you paid for. This is what happens when you stop choosing with your dick and start choosing with your brain. This is growth. This is maturity. This is what it looks like when you finally try something different.


So I tell myself: This isn't about physical. Give it a chance. Have a great time. You hired a matchmaker specifically to stop judging men by their jawline and start judging them by their character. Be evolved, J.R. Be the version of yourself that deserves love, not just lust.

So I relax. And honestly? Mr. Flatline makes it easy.


He's smart. Funny in a way that sneaks up on you—dry humor that lands soft instead of loud. The food comes—some fusion spot I picked because I'm a foodie and if the date goes south at least the meal will be good—and we talk about dream chefs and Top Chef and all the places we want to eat before we die.


It's good. He's good.


Conversation flows like we've known each other longer than an hour. No awkward silences. No desperate attempts to fill dead air. Just easy, natural, the kind of rhythm you can't force.

Then the conversation shifts to theater. Acting. The industry.


And something in me recoils.


I live this shit. I breathe this shit. Theater is my religion, my torture, my North Star and my albatross. It's the thing I love most and the thing that's broken my heart more times than any man ever could.


I don't want to talk about this shit on a date.


I want to escape it, not relive my audition trauma over overpriced Brussels sprouts. I want to be something other than Actor J.R., Writer J.R., the guy who can't stop performing even when the cameras are off.


But Mr. Flatline is engaged. Present. Listening like I'm the most fascinating person he's met all week. Asking follow-up questions that prove he's actually hearing me, not just waiting for his turn to talk.


And my penis? Still asleep. Not even a flicker.


I know you can't judge everything by that. I know attraction can grow. I know chemistry isn't always instant. I know I'm supposed to try something different, give nice guys a real chance, stop chasing the unavailable ones with perfect cheekbones and emotional intelligence of a doorknob.


I know all of this.


But boo, I need a little movement down there. Just a tiny bit. A pulse. A sign of life. Some indication that my body and my heart might eventually get on the same page instead of reading two completely different scripts.


Mr. Flatline's got no swag. No edge. No cat-and-mouse energy that makes dating feel like a game worth playing. Just kindness. Just consistency. Just presence.


Great on paper. Confusing in practice.


The date ends. We split the check because I'm not trying to owe anyone anything. We walk outside and the city noise swallows the silence between us.


He wants to see me again. I can see it in his face—the hope, the openness, the belief that this could be something if I just gave it time. If I just stopped expecting fireworks and learned to appreciate a slow burn.


And I'm standing there knowing I have to crush it.


Not because he did anything wrong. Not because he's not good enough. But because I can't force my body to want what my brain knows it should want. I can't manufacture chemistry like it's a prop I can pull out of my actor's toolkit and deploy when needed.

You can't will desire into existence. You can't negotiate with your dick like it's a union rep at a table read arguing for better working conditions.


I take a breath. Put on my big boy pants. Tell him the truth as gently as I know how: I think you're wonderful, but I need to move forward.


He takes it well. Gracefully, even. Like he knew before I said it. Like he felt the flatline too but was willing to try anyway.


Mr. Flatline was truly great.


And now I'm back where I started. Waiting for the next match. The next bio. The next lottery ticket purchased with loneliness and hope and money I don't have.

Here's what they don't tell you about matchmakers: Every profile is a test. Every date is evidence.


Evidence that maybe you're asking for too much. That maybe your standards are a shield protecting you from intimacy instead of a filter helping you find it.


Or evidence that you're finally asking for exactly what you deserve and refusing to settle for good enough when you've spent your whole life becoming worthy of extraordinary.

I don't know which one I am yet.


I pour a drink. Not whiskey this time—something lighter that lets me stay hopeful without burning on the way down. Something that won't make me dance on tables or text apologies I don't mean.


The phone sits on the table. Silent. Patient. Waiting with me like an old friend who's seen this movie before and knows how it ends but watches anyway.


Maybe the next one will make my heart and my body agree. Maybe kindness and heat can show up in the same man. Maybe I'll find someone who makes my brain light up AND my dick stand at attention, someone who passes both tests instead of just one.

Maybe I'll die waiting.


But at least I'm still here. Still playing the game. Still refusing to settle for good enough when I've worked this hard to become someone worthy of more.


The matchmaker will call again. They always do. They have to—I paid them.

And I'll say yes again. Because what else is there to do but keep trying? Keep hoping? Keep believing that somewhere in this city of eight million people, there's one man who'll make both my heart and my dick stand up and pay attention at the same time?

Until then, I wait.


Like Tevye's daughters waiting for the matchmaker to deliver their destiny. Like every actor before an audition waiting to hear their name called. Like every artist before the review drops waiting to find out if they're genius or fraud.


Waiting is what I do best.


And this time, I'm waiting for someone who doesn't just look good on paper.

I'm waiting for someone who makes the paper catch fire.




Comments


bottom of page